Not as good as the specs would lead but good for the price
For the price I would say that the camera is worth it.
There's not much else to choose from in the price range.
Pros:
Cheap lightweight small 16x zoom.
Cons:
Grainy especially in low light menus and features could
be better still picture worthless.
Details:
The video in low light is grainy. Even in bright outdoor
light the image shows grain. There are 3 gain options
-- none AGC and Auto-A. Using none there is little grain
but colors are washed. AGC is unacceptably grainy and
Auto-A is a little grainy but colors are bright. I've been
shooting in Auto-A.
Stills are not only noisy but resolution is poor. I feel
the packaging is very misleading in this regard. The camera
advertises a 680k CCD and 1024x768 still resolution. The
1024x768 still image according to the manual is actually shot
in 720x480 resolution and interpolated upwards. That's actually
only using half the available CCD pixels. They should have
used the full 680k for the 1024x768 image. This pretty much
means you will get the best results using 640x480 mode and
interpolating yourself (interpolating 720x480 to 1024x768 is
lossy and there are better enlarging methods than what they
use).
The menus are too complicated for the features they control.
I would like to know how the arpature shutter speed and gain
are being controlled and control these myself for the best
image quality. The automatic settings for each of these don't
do the best job. It's also not easy to get to these settings
on the fly -- the single wheel control and menus are difficult
to traverse while shooting.
The image stabilization works well in bright light. It doesn't
seem to work as well in Auto-A (auto arpature) setting for some
reason. This is a problem because Auto-A produces a better
image than AGC or no-gain. I'd like to use Auto-A and get
good image stabilization too.
Night alive is almost useless. Basically it slows the shutter
speed way down to capture more light. When you use it you get
nothing but motion blur. I wish they had manual controls of the
shutter arpature and gain because this would allow me to
produce a better nighttime image. I did use the Night Alive
setting to take a still photo in the dark using a tripod and
this produces the least grain of any mode.
Compared to the 30U and 90U models -- I'd almost recomend the
30U since the still quality of the 70u and 90u is not good.
The 90U has a larger LCD screen but the size of the 30u and
70u is good enough. The 90u comes with an 8mb memory card
but if you are going to use the memory card you will buy a
larger one anyways and end up not using the 8mb card. The
70u comes with a remote control which I will use (so I can
be in the video -- like at Christmastime)
Wishlist:
1) Use the full CCD for stills.
2) Manual shutter speed (min currently is 1/60th but if it
could be set to 1/30th this could vastly improve indoor
stills and video. 1/15th could work well for extreme dark
lighting.) Along this vein an arpature and a shutter
priority mode would be nice.
3) Progressive scan video.
4) Direct access controls to arpature shutter and gain -
the menus are too difficult to fumble through and the
naming in the menus are not easy to figure out what they
do.
5) Titles and ***Date/Time*** capability on firewire capture.
6) Use full CCD for video capture -- this would disable the
stabilization but could produce a brighter more
accurate image.More detail ...